Freedom or Security?


"They who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." — Benjamin Franklin

We all want to live in a safe world, but what are we willing to sacrifice? This is a question that lies at the heart of "Captain America: The Winter Soldier." SHIELD is working on a plan to keep the world safe. But to do that, they have to tread upon the rights and privacy of the world.

Nick Fury (Samuel L. Jackson) sees it as a necessary step for the world we live in. Captain America (Chris Evans), who was born of a different time and generation, sees it as sacrificing too much. This is not a new question — either in terms of modern entertainment or age old debates. How much can and should we sacrifice for freedom.

Our Founding Fathers knew that this was something to be considered. Franklin's quote gets at the heart of that. But with the increase in terror threats, and the increase in technology, the line between security and privacy has never been thinner.

"Captain America" is a Marvel comic movie. It's an action movie. It's popcorn entertainment. But woven in that is a serious topic, that the filmmakers take seriously, too. They don't really have a great answer for the question, but they want the audience to ponder it.

Those that don't watch the news may not realize it, but our government has been treading close to — or perhaps over, depending on your viewpoint — that line for a while. There will soon come a day when, as citizens, we'll be forced to declare just how much privacy we're willing to sacrifice for security.

Of course, "Captain America" isn't the only piece of pop culture entertainment to tackle this subject. Many shows and movies have talked about the free flow of information and one — "Person of Interest" — is even built around the idea the government is spying on us for our own good, and what that might mean.

We all want to be safe, but we want the freedom to live our lives. This country was founded on those ideas of freedom, yet we seem to be on the leading edge of curbing that freedom for security. The question we must consider is whether that is where we want to be?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Burial a courtroom drama with heart

Image
Willie Gary (Jamie Foxx) is a brash trial lawyer who is good at rallying a jury to his cause. Jeremiah O’Keefe (Tommy Lee Jones) is a quiet grandfather who is trying to ensure the business his family built remains viable after he’s gone. These two don’t appear to have much in common on the surface. But when they’re brought together by young lawyer Hal Dockins (Mamoudou Athie) brings them together, a connection is formed over their shared background of working hard to become self-made men. And it turned out that Willie was just who Jerry needed in his corner to win the fight of his life. The new Prime Video film The Burial, which opened in theaters October 6 and started streaming October 13, captures that trial against the Loewen Group that changed the course of their lives. The film is based on the true story and covers the trial, but more importantly captures the relationship between the men. The film plays out like a traditional courtroom drama. Foxx is solid as Willie Gary, while Ju...
Read more

Broncos Draft Targets

Image
  The NFL Draft is just a few days away. On April 25, the Denver Broncos will head into the draft in the midst of something of a rebuild. In the draft, the Broncos have the No. 12 pick in Round 1, then have a Third Round Pick, Fourth Round Pick, three Fifth Round Picks, a Sixth Round Pick, and a Seventh Round Pick. So, what might they be targeting? Let's dive in and look at possible positions. Quarterback : The team clearly needs a long-term quarterback. Jarrett Stidham and Ben DiNucci are there but the team could certainly use someone else. Could they move up for Drake Maye or J.J. McCarthy? Yes, they could. Will the take Bo Nix at 12? It's possible. Or will the Broncos wait until next off-season to make a move? Anything is in play for the Broncos in 2024, but quarterback is surely a need. Tight End: The team brought back Adam Trautman and still has Greg Dulcich, but it's still a need. Dulcich hasn't been able to get on the field and Trautman hasn't been great. Co...
Read more

Favorite Westerns, No. 43

Image
  Do you like a good Western? It's a classic genre in film and this year I've decided to look at some of my favorite Westerns. So, join me each Friday as I count down my favorite Westerns from No. 50 to No. 1. Rooster Cogburn : [ watching Mattie ford the river hanging on the back of her horse] By God. She reminds me of me. True Grit (1969) Starring : John Wayne, Kim Darby, Glen Campbell, Robert Duvall, and Dennis Hopper Director : Henry Hathaway About: This is the third straight week with a film from Wayne. As you might guess, we're not done. As I've mentioned, he sets a standard for the genre. Here, we seen him bring to life an iconic character. This one is based on a novel, and it has endured. He's great as Rooster Cogburn, so good that he got a sequel in the same character. But this is a later film in his career. This is a different, more grizzled Wayne. He's still quite good and this is a film that really has stood the test of time. It's not the only ve...
Read more